Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrators: Which is Your Perfect Pick

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrators are two heavyweights that stand out in the market. These appliances have their unique strengths and features, and in this comparison, we’ll dive into the details to help you make an informed decision.

 One crucial aspect of food dehydration is ensuring even air circulation, and both these models excel in this regard with strategically placed fans. They also offer temperature control, but the range can vary. 

Additionally, the presence of timers is another factor to consider, as well as the overall drying capacity. Finally, the design and tray shape can impact your choice based on your kitchen setup and preferences.

Difference Between Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Fan Placement

Getting air to flow evenly is important for drying food. Both the Magic Mill Pro and Excalibur stainless steel dehydrators do this well.

They have fans in the back that blow warm air sideways, making sure everything dries the same.

This design means you don’t have to keep moving the trays, and it’s easy to clean because food doesn’t get to the fan.

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator: Temperature Control

Being able to set the right temperature is crucial for drying food properly. Both the Magic Mill Pro and Excalibur dehydrators let you adjust the heat. But there’s a difference in the range they can go.

The Magic Mill Pro can go from 95°F to 158°F, which is good for different kinds of drying. On the other hand, most Excalibur models can go from 95°F to 165°F, except for one model that can go higher.

Timer Function

Managing time is important when drying food. Excalibur’s non-commercial stainless steel models come with timers that can be set for a long time, either 26 or 99 hours, depending on the model.

But not all Excalibur models have timers. The Magic Mill Pro has a timer you can set for up to 19.5 hours, giving you control over your drying.


When comparing the Magic Mill Pro and Excalibur’s stainless steel models, think about how much space you have to dry food, not just the number of trays.

Excalibur’s stainless steel models have trays that are 15 x 15 inches, which gives you about 225 square inches of drying space per tray. In comparison, the Magic Mill Pro has trays that are 13″ x 12″ and gives you 156 square inches per tray. So, pick the one that fits your drying needs.

Looks and Design

Both dehydrators look good and are practical. But it’s good to know that the Magic Mill Pro uses rectangular trays, while the Excalibur model uses square ones. This might matter depending on how your kitchen is set up and what you like.

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Tray Shape

The choice between rectangular and square trays can impact your ability to efficiently utilize space and dehydrate various types of food. Rectangular or square trays are ideal for drying long pieces or strips of food, making them a practical choice.

In contrast, round trays with a hole in the middle are less efficient when it comes to drying longer pieces.

Magic Mill Dehydrator Overview

The Magic Mill MFD-7070 Dehydrator is a stainless steel powerhouse for food preservation. With seven large trays, each capable of holding up to 1.47 pounds of food, it can process at least 7 pounds of food in one go.

Whether you’re drying fruits, vegetables, herbs, or meats, it delivers high-performance results. Despite its impressive capacity, it boasts an elongated, space-saving design, making it perfect for those with limited kitchen space.

Durable and efficient, it’s a versatile choice for anyone looking to preserve or create delicious, shelf-stable snacks and ingredients.

>> Related post: Magic Mill Dehydrator Review: 03 Top-rated Models


  • Affordable price
  • Features automatic shut off when dehydrating is complete
  • Transparent design allows you to see inside while the machine is on
  • All trays are dishwasher-friendly for easy cleaning
  • Simple and easy-to-clean both inside and out
  • Compact size, doesn’t take up too much space
  • User-friendly and straightforward operation


  • Limited capacity for the amount of food it can hold
  • Temperature and time guidelines may not be entirely accurate
  • Can produce a slightly burnt smell

What’s in the box?

  • A dehydrator,
  • 7 drying trays
  • 2 non-stick trays
  • 2 gloves
  • Manuals and warranty cards

Who should buy the Magic Mill Dehydrator?

The Magic Mill Dehydrator is an ideal choice for a wide range of individuals. Beginners to food dehydration will appreciate its user-friendly design and versatility, as it can easily handle the drying of various foods, from fruits to meats.

Moreover, its affordability makes it a smart investment for those looking to explore food preservation without breaking the bank. The added value of two sets of trays and mesh sheets as accessories enhances its utility.

Additionally, its compact size is a boon for those with limited kitchen or home space, allowing them to enjoy the benefits of food dehydration without compromising on valuable space.

Whether you’re a novice or simply seeking a convenient and budget-friendly way to preserve and enjoy your favorite foods, the Magic Mill Dehydrator is a worthy addition to your kitchen arsenal.

Excalibur Dehydrator 3900B Overview

The Excalibur Dehydrator is a powerhouse in the world of food dehydration. With its impressive nine easy-to-clean trays and a sprawling 15 square feet of drying space, it offers ample room to preserve a wide variety of foods.

Its adjustable thermostat, ranging from 105 to 165 degrees Fahrenheit, ensures precise control, making it suitable for fruits, vegetables, and meats. What sets the Excalibur apart is its commitment to preserving the nutritional value of your food. It operates at low temperatures, safeguarding essential nutrients and enzymes.

The Excalibur’s innovative Hyperwave technology and horizontal Parallex drying ensure faster and more efficient dehydration without the need for tray rotation. As an added bonus, it comes with a digital guide to dehydration, making the process even more user-friendly.

Crafted in the USA with globally sourced materials, the Excalibur Dehydrator is a testament to quality and functionality, making it a trusted companion for all your food preservation needs.


  • Uses Hyperwave technology for safe food items
  • Adjustable thermostat for different types of foods
  • Back-mounted fan and strong motor for even heat distribution
  • Massive drying surface
  • Made in the USA, sturdy and well-built
  • Precise temperature control knob
  • 9 square trays for easy arrangement of food items


  • Cannot add more trays
  • Bulky design takes up a lot of space in small kitchens
  • Does not have a timer
  • Onboard ON/OFF switch would be helpful
  • Some users find it to be a bit louder

What’s in the box?

  • Main dehydrator unit
  • 9 dehydrating trays
  • Flexible poly-screen tray inserts
  • Recipe guide
  • User manual
  • Warranty card

Who Should Buy The Excalibur Food Dehydrator?

The Excalibur Dehydrator is a great fit for anyone who wants to preserve food easily. It has nine trays and lots of space to dry fruits, veggies, and meat. You can set the temperature just right, so your food keeps its nutrients.

It works well for both new and experienced users, and it even comes with a digital guide to help you. Plus, it’s made in the USA, which means it’s reliable and good quality.

Final Verdict: Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

In the battle of Magic Mill vs Excalibur dehydrators, both machines offer unique advantages. The Magic Mill is a great pick for beginners, with affordability and compact size as its strong suits. It’s versatile and comes with accessories, making it a convenient choice for those with limited kitchen space.

On the other hand, the Excalibur dehydrator is a powerhouse with nine trays and ample drying space. It stands out with its ability to preserve nutrients and its efficient drying technology. However, it comes at a higher price point. The choice ultimately depends on your needs and preferences.

If you’re just starting out and want a budget-friendly option, Magic Mill is the way to go. For seasoned users seeking maximum drying capacity and nutrient preservation, the Excalibur is worth the investment.


In terms of price, Magic Mill dehydrators are generally more affordable than Excalibur dehydrators. Magic Mill offers a range of dehydrators with different sizes and features, so the price can vary depending on the specific model. However, in general, Magic Mill dehydrators are priced lower than Excalibur dehydrators.

It’s worth noting that while Magic Mill dehydrators are more affordable, they may not have all the features or the same level of quality as Excalibur dehydrators. If you’re looking for a dehydrator that can handle heavy use and has advanced features, you may want to consider investing in an Excalibur dehydrator.

Ultimately, the choice between a Magic Mill and Excalibur dehydrator will depend on your specific needs and budget.

Both Magic Mill and Excalibur dehydrators offer excellent temperature control.

However, Excalibur dehydrators are known for their precise and consistent temperature control, which is essential for dehydrating different types of foods evenly.

Excalibur dehydrators also have a wider temperature range, which allows for more versatility in dehydrating different types of foods.

The trays of Magic Mill and Excalibur dehydrators are not interchangeable. Each brand has its own specific tray design and size, so they are not compatible with each other.

It is recommended to use trays that are specifically designed for your dehydrator model to ensure proper fit and functionality.

Conclusion: Magic Mill vs Excalibur dehydrator

In the Magic Mill vs Excalibur dehydrator showdown, the decision ultimately comes down to your specific needs and priorities. The Magic Mill Pro is an excellent choice for beginners and those with limited kitchen space, thanks to its affordability, compact size, and user-friendly design.

On the other hand, the Excalibur Dehydrator boasts a larger drying capacity, precise temperature control, and a commitment to preserving nutrients, making it a top pick for experienced users willing to invest in a premium appliance.

Your choice should align with your budget, kitchen space, and your desire for either a practical starter or a high-capacity, nutrient-preserving food dehydrator.

You might be interested:

Nesco vs Excalibur Dehydrator: An In-Depth Comparison

Magic Mill vs Cosori Dehydrator: Which One is the Ultimate Choice for Your Kitchen?

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

We receive compensation on qualifying purchases as an Amazon Associate. is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate marketing initiative created to give websites the opportunity to make money by promoting and linking to

Review Kitchen Equipments