Magic Mill vs Cosori Dehydrator: Which One is the Ultimate Choice for Your Kitchen?

In the realm of dehydrators, where culinary magic unfolds, the battle between Magic Mill Vs Cosori Dehydrator ignites. Prepare to witness a captivating showdown as we explore the enchanting powers of these two titans, comparing the wonders of Magic Mill to the spellbinding capabilities of Cosori. 

Join us on a journey through the world of food preservation and discover which of these magical dehydrators reign supreme: Magic Mill or Cosori?

Specifications

Difference Between Magic Mill vs Cosori Dehydrator

Fan position

Both have rear-mounted fans.

The Magic Mill dehydrator and Cosori Dehydrator feature rear-mounted fans, which blow hot air horizontally and evenly dehydrate food on all trays. This eliminates the need to rotate the trays for even dehydration. Additionally, the fan’s location at the back of the dehydrator prevents drippings from fruits, vegetables, and meats from soiling the fan.

Adjustable Thermostat

The Cosori offers a slightly wider temperature range than Magic Mill Model. 

Proper temperature control is crucial to achieving optimal results with any food dehydrator. 

Insufficient heat can lead to spoiled or fermented food, while excessive heat can damage the enzymes and nutrients in raw foods that promote good health. 

The Magic Mill Pro and Excalibur dehydrators feature adjustable thermostats, but the Cosori dehydrator offers a slightly broader temperature range (95°F to 165°F) than the Magic Mill model.

The Cosori offers a slightly wider temperature range.

Capacity

Magic Mill trays provide more drying space.

Dehydrators offer a generous space for drying fruits, vegetables, herbs, and more. The Cosori dehydrator, with its 6 trays, provides ample room for dehydration, allowing you to dry various items simultaneously. 

On the other hand, the Magic Mill takes it a step further with 7 trays, providing an additional tray for even more drying capacity. This extra tray can be advantageous if you have larger batches or a wider variety of items to dehydrate. 

Appearance & Design

When comparing the design and appearance of the Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrator models, there are several notable similarities and differences.

 In terms of appearance, both dehydrators feature a transparent door, allowing you to easily monitor the dehydration process without opening the unit. 

This feature is practical and convenient for users who want to watch their food closely. 

While the Magic Mill dehydrator comes in a single-color option, the Cosori model offers more variety with two color choices: black and grey. This allows users to choose a color that best suits their kitchen aesthetic or personal preference. 

The Cosori offers a slightly wider temperature range.

Dehydrators showcase sleek and contemporary designs, fitting seamlessly into modern kitchen spaces. The clean lines and compact sizes make them visually appealing and easy to integrate into any countertop setup. 

Another similarity between the two models is using a digital touch-control panel, which allows for precise temperature and time adjustments. 

This user-friendly interface simplifies the operation of the dehydrators, making it easy for beginners and experienced users alike to navigate the settings. 

Noise level

Cosori dehydrator tends to be quieter.

The Magic Mill and Cosori dehydrators have fans that can produce noise during operation. However, based on customer reviews and product specifications, the Cosori dehydrator tends to be quieter than the Magic Mill. 

Some customers have described the Magic Mill as loud, while others have not found it to be a significant issue. Ultimately, the noise level may depend on personal preference and tolerance.

>> How Does a Dehydrator Work?

Magic Mill Dehydrator Overview

The Magic Mill MFD-7070 dehydrator is an affordable and efficient machine that can significantly affect how you prepare and preserve food.

It is made of stainless steel and equipped with seven large-size trays, each capable of holding up to 1.47 lbs of food. With a total capacity of at least 7 pounds, this dehydrator is ideal for heavy-duty use and high-performance drying of various foods, from fruits to meat.

It has an elongated design that makes it less bulky than other dehydrators, making it perfect for individuals with limited kitchen space.

One of the main benefits of the Magic Mill dehydrator is its even heat distribution. The rear-mounted fan and heating element work together to ensure that your food is dehydrated evenly, without any hot spots. 

Pros

• Budget-friendly.
• It has an automatic shut-off function that stops the machine once the dehydration process is complete.
• It has a transparent window.
• All trays are dishwasher-safe, and the machine is easy to clean.
• Its compact size makes it ideal for kitchens with limited space.
• It is straightforward to operate.
• This dehydrator utilizes air flow circulation technology to ensure the drying process is even.

Cons

• It can be quite noisy when used, which may be a problem for some users. 
• The trays are not adjustable, which may limit the types of food that you can dehydrate.

What’s in the box?

• 1 dehydrator.
• 7 drying trays.
• 2 non-stick trays.
• 2 gloves.
• Manuals and warranty cards.

Who should buy the Magic Mill Dehydrator?

If you’re new to dehydrating food, the Magic Mill dehydrator is an excellent choice. It is beginner-friendly and can dehydrate various foods, including fruits and meats.

The affordability of this high-performance machine makes it a smart investment for those who want to save money while still enjoying the benefits of a food dehydrator. 

Additionally, it comes with accessories, including two sets of trays and mesh sheets, which help you save even more money. 

The Magic Mill dehydrator is compact and can fit in small spaces, making it ideal for people with limited kitchen or home space.

Cosori Dehydrator Overview

The Cosori Food Dehydrator Machine is an average-sized device that offers precise time and temperature settings. 

The exterior has a sleek and modern-industrial appearance, while the interior is relatively easy to clean. 

However, the tightly woven metal wire trays tend to make food stick to them, which is our only complaint. If you prioritize aesthetics when choosing kitchen appliances, this machine may be the perfect fit for you.

 Pros

• The machine features an easy-to-use interface with three temperature and timing settings buttons. 
• The trays are crafted using 304 food-grade stainless steel, which makes them safer, more long-lasting, and suitable for cleaning in a dishwasher.
• The temperature controls on it are precise.
• This Cosori 6 tray dehydrator is quiet in use, with noise levels of less than 48dB
• Nice looking transparent door.
• Fully-equipped. 
• Worth the money. 

Cons

• This manufacturer is not as well-known as the leading brand.
• It has limited capacity.
• The dehydrator includes one mesh screen and one fruit roll sheet.

What’s in the box?

• The stainless steel dehydrator.
• 6 metal trays 
• One solid fruit leather tray.
• 1 mesh sheet for drying small tiny items like herbs and such
• The Cookbook of Recipes.
• Manuals and warranty cards.

Who Should Buy The Cosori Food Dehydrator?

If you want a stainless steel dehydrator but don’t want to spend a lot of money on it, the Cosori CP267-FD is a great option. 

It is a full-featured food dehydrator that is easy to operate and clean and is made of high-quality materials. 

However, it has a capacity limit of 6.5 square feet, which may not be sufficient for those who need to process large quantities of food, such as hunters or avid gardeners. Despite being a lesser-known manufacturer, customer feedback has been excellent so far.

Owners have praised this machine for producing consistently good results with various foods, including jerky, fruits, and vegetables. As one reviewer put it, this affordable dehydrator delivers quality performance.

Final Verdict: Magic Mill vs Cosori Dehydrator

When comparing the two models, there are several factors to consider. Regarding capacity and adjustability, the COSORI dehydrator has an advantage with its adjustable trays. However, the Magic Mill dehydrator has an advantage in terms of even heat distribution.

In terms of noise level, the COSORI dehydrator is the clear winner. It is much quieter than the Magic Mill dehydrator, making it ideal for use in smaller spaces or when you don’t want to disturb others.

Overall, both models have their pros and cons. If you prioritize even heat distribution and don’t mind a bit of noise, then the Magic Mill dehydrator may be your better choice. However, if you prioritize quiet operation and adjustable trays, then the COSORI dehydrator may be a better fit.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing between the Magic Mill Food Dehydrator MFD-7070 and the COSORI Food Dehydrator CP267-FD depends on your specific needs and preferences. Both models have their strengths and weaknesses, so it’s important to consider the factors most important to you before deciding.

Overall, we recommend both models as great options for anyone looking for a high-quality dehydrator. Whether you choose the Magic Mill or the COSORI, you can enjoy healthy snacks and preserve your food for longer.

You might be interested: 

• Nesco Gardenmaster Dehydrator Review: Comparing FD-1040 vs FD-108A Models
• Cosori Dehydrator vs Excalibur: Which One is Right for You?

FAQs – Magic Mill Vs Cosori Dehydrator